Carragher also questioned Neville's choice of Amorim as a "Manager to Watch". Neville defended his pick by saying that he knew that if Amorim started badly, he would be under a lot of pressure to turn things around. Many people might think United will not finish in the top four this season, but some are hopeful after their summer transfer business, which has added new players to the team, especially in attack. The new signings, including Bryan Mbeumo, Matheus Cunha, and Benjamin Sesko, could help United improve their chances of finishing in the top four.

During the discussion, Sky Sports presenter David Jones shared a surprising fact about Manchester United fans' expectations. He said that only 13% of fans think the team will finish in the top four. Neville jokingly replied that he had to include himself in that 1% who thought United would do well, as he wanted to be able to come back to the show in 10 months and defend his prediction.